Hey Harry,
I'm not into what style looks more original or not, but I can say that in my own experience the vinyl stickers doesn't work that good when you have to put a clear paint on top of it. It's too thick for that. I often have this problem with Norton logos on antique tanks.
I prefer to use the waterslides from Mark (Crazy Horse Australia).
All the best
Manny

Thanks Manny and Tim!  Manny, the Crazyhorse decals I have are actually vinyl, quite nicely done but still more like a sticker than a waterslide.

And Tim, thanks for the picture, it shows exactly what I'm worried about...a graphic that sits off the surface of the tank versus being almost painted onto the tank as they might have appeared originally.

I'm being too "picky" perhaps, but I have a very nice new paint job and I don't want to "shortchange it" by applying a graphic that appears to be a sticker when it wasn't made that way originally.

The Walker decal looks best, if only it were a waterslide!

...just to wrap this up, I found a set of waterslide decals that I'm going to use.  They're a tiny bit fatter than the Walker vinyl stickers, but not as chubby as the others.  I pretty much decided that I only wanted to use waterslide.  (...and I've got some of my "rejects" to pass along if anyone is interested)

Picture shows the very nice Walker vinyl stickers on the top compared to the waterslides I'm going to use:

These waterslide decals came from John Berry in Davenport, Iowa.  No website and he didn't reply to e-mails...so I phoned him at 563-370-0881 .  He was referred to me by Rick Simpson of Rick's decals (ricksdecals03@gmail.com )

Hope that helps!

Hey Harry what reject decals are you not wanting?